The All That Christmas Special, produced and aired as the tenth episode of the show's second season, originally aired on December 23, 1995. Its special musical guest was Run DMC.
- Green Room-Meet Santa: The kids meet Santa and give him some odd requests for Christmas presents. Katrina asks for a cordless phone (after being forced to chose between that and world peace). Kel asks for $50 on the spot. Alisa asks for a long list of expensive items and some bacon. Josh asks for a computer (even though he's Jewish). Lori Beth admits she hasn't been a good girl this year and leaves. Angelique asks for Denzel Washington. Kenan asks for a big screen TV, only to have Santa tell him he's on the Naughty List.
- Holiday Cooking With Randy & Mandy: Randy and Mandy show viewers some delicious chocolatey recipes for the holiday season. There's a turkey stuffed and basted with chocolate, some choco-motzah ball soup with chocolate balls and broth, and the Super Special Chocolate Milkshake, which is for any day!
- Superdude Saves Christmas: While delivering some presents, Santa spies cookies and milk and tries to eat them-but he is trapped in a cage instead! Milkman is up to his usual tricks-he wants to ruin Christmas! He takes Santa to his secret lair, but Penny Lane soon shows up...along with Superdude, who was hiding in a giant present! Santa is freed and uses some karate on Milkman to beat him severely, leaving Superdude to save the day.
- Holiday French with Pierre Escargot: Pierre wishes us a "Joyeux Noelle" with his Christmasy phrases in French.
- Christmas Lemonade Scammer
- Peter & Flem: Peter gets presents from Santa because he is a good boy. Flem gets presents, too - but only because he steals them.
- The Girls' Christmas Carol
- Mavis and Clavis introduce the musical guest - Run DMC, performing "Christmas In Hollis".
- Santa's line "Take your milky paws off me, you filthy ape!" is a reference to a similar line from Planet of the Apes.
- The iTunes release of the episode cuts out The Girls' Christmas Carol sketch and Run DMC's performance at the end. This version of the episode was also the version featured on the official The '90s Are All That website in December 2011.
|Angelique Bates|| Mandy|
|Lori Beth Denberg||?|
|Katrina Johnson||Lemonade Scammer|
|Kel Mitchell|| Peter|
|Josh Server|| Milkman|
|Kenan Thompson|| Randy|